Whoop(s)ie! This blog needs a new name!

My quest to start a whoopie pie stand of my very own in a Chicago farmers market.

‘RoonReview: Mad Mac NYC…er, NJ

Well, Florian Bellanger (seen here at 40 seconds with a classic Florian line), I am unimpressed.  Or en français: Je ne suis pas impressioné.

Pastry Chefs Florian Bellanger and Ludovic Augendre, the founders of Mad Mac

As I mentioned before, I purchased this nice little package from Gilt Taste.  Although they’re hyped on Gilt Taste as “Mad Mac NYC” and supposedly these macarons are sold in hotels and restaurants across New York City, if you do a wee bit of searching on the Mad Mac website, you’ll find that Mad Mac is actually located in New Jersey.  Not that living in NYC for five years gave me any kind of prejudice against New Jersey…ahem…but there is something to be said for the false advertising.  At least they came packaged impressively.

This was inside a foil bubble wrap pocket with an ice pack inside a small cardboard box. Only one broken macaron on the upper right. Not bad.

And they look even better out of the packaging.

top row: white chocolate sesame, middle: chocolate hazelnut; bottom: vanilla

They are listed for the same price on Gilt Taste and the Mad Mac website.  The price difference (i.e. deal) comes from the difference in shipping.  Shipping on Gilt Taste was an additional $9.95, so in all, each macaron cost roughly $2.50, which is actually cheaper than the going rate for Laduree’s macarons in New York City.  If you buy from the Mad Mac website, you first have to meet a $35 minimum and then have to pay either Next Day or 2nd Day shipping, which for me came out to a whopping $19.96 or $48.63 respectively.

So were they good enough to justify the regular prices listed above?  Definitely not.  Almost disappointing actually.  I had my family over for an apartment warming party and we sampled.

don't let the smile fool you...that was really directed at the wine

I’ll start with the good: clearly they look gorgeous – wonderful matte, satiny shell, uniform size, cute little sesame seeds.  The texture was almost perfect, and that’s super impressive considering what these little babies went through (overnight shipping on a Thursday night which I couldn’t accept from UPS because I wasn’t home, so then there was probably some sitting in a cool UPS truck for 3 days, delivery on Monday, freezer till Saturday, and then a defrost on my counter for several hours).  Some of us (perhaps those without very developed palates) even preferred the texture.  The chocolate and white chocolate were both soft.  Not really any crispy outer layer, but they weren’t mushy or unpleasant in any way.  The vanilla did have a better slight crisp with a soft interior, but that’s where my praise of the vanilla will end.  It didn’t taste like anything.  I’ve got to say Vanille‘s vanilla is still my favorite.  Those people know how to make vanilla taste good.

The chocolate hazelnut was very enjoyable aside from the texture; very nutty with chocolate taking a bit of a back seat to the hazelnut.  The filling itself also had a supremely smooth decadent texture, almost caramel-like.  The boyfriend thought Delightful‘s chocolate was better, but I don’t think that’s a fair comparison since their chocolate tasted so much like a brownie that it would be like comparing a chocolate hazelnut macaron with a dense, fudgy brownie.

yeah, chocolate! (my big bro, Paul)

he was all "meh"

The white chocolate sesame was the biggest disappointment of all.  I thought “oo!  An unusual flavor combo! This has to be interesting!”  But apparently it doesn’t.

so excited!

"wait...where's the sesame?"

It tasted like neither white chocolate nor sesame; it just tasted blandly sweet.  My last bite had the faintest hint of sesame, so there must have been just a few more seeds on it than my other bites, but it was far from an original, unusual taste.  They also had this annoying crumbly problem…

nom! (my other big bro, Tom)

and then…

aww man...macaron beard

Just kidding…all macarons have that problem.

So there you go.  Bennison’s still kicks these fancy “New York” macarons’ shells.

Photo-bettering credit has to go once again to my friend, Steph.  Check out her awesome design shop here.


3 comments on “‘RoonReview: Mad Mac NYC…er, NJ

  1. Blind Blog
    October 26, 2011

    Hi, I really enjoyed reading your article. As a blind food critic, I have now sampled macarons from 9 different stores here in NYC with Laduree being my clear favorite. (It should be noted that I went to one of the original Laduree stores in Paris which was my first mind blowing macaron experience) If you ever need help tasting macarons, I specialize in blind taste tests and it might be a fun thing to try! Here’s my site if you’re interested:

  2. Pingback: ‘RoonReview: Slurping Turtle « macmaker

  3. ana
    February 11, 2012

    The best macarons in NYC are those from Madeleine,La Maison du Macaron at 6h avenue and 23rd street.

Comment? Question? Suggestion?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on October 12, 2011 by in 'RoonReviews, Macaron, Pictures...pretty, pretty pictures and tagged , , , , .

The Archives

My Tumblr

My Foodspotting Sightings

%d bloggers like this: