Whoop(s)ie! This blog needs a new name!

My quest to start a whoopie pie stand of my very own in a Chicago farmers market.

‘RoonReview: Bittersweet Pastry Shop

I recently made the rough journey…okay, 25-minute walk on one of the nicest days we’ve had in a while…to Bittersweet Pastry Shop with my boyfriend and a few old friends to try some macarons.  If you’ve never been, I would highly recommend going if not for the gorgeous pastries, at least for the clean, chic atmosphere.  It’s just a really beautiful, light-filled cafe (and it doesn’t hurt that both times I’ve gone they’ve had mouthwatering samples of their cake at the door).

I mean just look at the table decoration:


And the scrumptious café au lait:


Anyway, the macarons: they had four available flavors.

Clockwise from left: almond, chocolate, raspberry, and pistachio

I have been to Bittersweet before, but it was pre-macaron-stand-dreams, so while I did try the macarons, I didn’t really pay them enough attention.  However, this time you can be sure I paid them enough attention.  As did my companions.

Liz loved the chocolate

Irene pre-last-minute-pistachio-macaron-addition

Bittersweet macarons in one word: different.  In a few words connected by ellipsis: not really macarons…more cookies.  They’re fine if you like cookies and cookie sandwiches, but these really lacked the light, crispy shell, soft interior feel of what I think of when I think macaron.  The almond was especially bizarre.  Some thoughts on the almond included, “it’s hard!” and “kind of stiff” and  “it’s like an Oreo.”

“No, it’s not crumbly like an Oreo.  A stale Oreo maybe.”

My boyfriend took a bite of the almond and all of the filling shot out of the sides.  Really?  I feel like that’s kind of unheard of in a macaron.  They all were served straight out of the cooler, and this shooting-out-the-sides phenomenon happened even after I allowed them a good 10 minute warm-up.  I know first hand that temperature has a big influence on macarons, and I’ve seen that said elsewhere.  Cold buttercream just isn’t a desirable texture, so I think Bittersweet’s macarons would fare much better if kept on top of or next to the refrigerated case instead of inside.  But alas, I do not run Bittersweet.

As for the other flavors, Cassie said the raspberry was “intense” and that she felt the sugar flowing directly into her veins.

Cassie and Elizabeth - not the biggest fans of Bittersweet's macarons

I thought the raspberry was the most traditional in texture, and had quite a good complex flavor.  A bit chewy in texture like the others though.  The pistachio was also good, but standard in flavor.  Maybe the only one I would order again.

You caught me!

Pat really liked the pistachio...he may have even raved about it a little bit.

The chocolate was…

…well let’s just say it wouldn’t win any macaron beauty contests.  It looks like they just didn’t grind their almonds fine enough, resulting in a super bumpy shell.

It also wouldn’t win any macaron texture contests as evidenced by my face at first bite:


The ganache, while intensely chocolatey and delicious, was extremely dense.  The cookie itself was also thick and toothsome.  It was just a good chocolate cookie, but I wouldn’t call it a macaron.  I’m not even being a snob or macaron purist (really, guys!).  It was just completely crispy shell-less.

If I had to compare these to Vanille’s, I would say the chocolate certainly beat Vanille’s in terms of flavor, but Vanille has Bittersweet knocked out cold in terms of texture across the board.  Maybe they were just old.  Maybe they were just cold.  Either way, they just weren’t macaron-y.

Just for fun (because macarons are supposed to be fun):


One comment on “‘RoonReview: Bittersweet Pastry Shop

  1. Sanita
    September 14, 2011

    I enjoy seeing all my favorite faces. I’d like a macaron!

Comment? Question? Suggestion?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on September 14, 2011 by in 'RoonReviews, Macaron, Pictures...pretty, pretty pictures and tagged , , , , , .

The Archives

My Tumblr

My Foodspotting Sightings

%d bloggers like this: